Investing

How Stockspot outperformed Vanguard and robo advisors

Three strategies that have helped the Stockspot portfolios outperform Vanguard and other ETF peers over the last 5 years.

Robo advice has grown globally by more than 1,000% over the past 5 years as more people manage their investments with the assistance of digital advice. There is now over $400 billion invested in robo advice around the world.

Source: U.S. Global Investors

The recent share market sell-off related to COVID-19 has highlighted significant differences in performance between diversified fund managers. In our March 2020 performance update we showed that the Stockspot portfolios had been able to beat 99% of diversified funds across 1, 3, and 5 years.

There are 3 main reasons Stockspot clients were able to outperform almost all diversified funds and robo advisers over the last 5 years.

  1. A greater weighting to defensive assets
  2. Selecting the best low cost ETFs
  3. Rebalancing at the right time

1. A greater weighting to defensive assets

We know that your mix of assets drives about 90% of differences in returns. It’s therefore critical to have the right mix of growth and defensive assets in any balanced portfolio. Many fund managers (including super funds) had been increasing their exposure to growth assets over the last few years and at the same time including risky assets such as heavily geared property and infrastructure in their defensive allocations. It is always tempting when markets are booming to move up the risk curve to squeeze out some extra performance. But a rapid downturn like in the first quarter of 2020 shows how dangerous this strategy can be.

Listed property and infrastructure fell by 40% across February and March and were shown not to have the defensive characteristics of bonds and gold. We discussed this in detail in our recent expose of the aggressive investment strategy of super fund Hostplus.

In our view a defensive asset has 2 essential qualities: 

1) it holds its value in a downturn and 
2) it can be liquidated easily in a stressed market. 

This is one reason we increased our allocation to government bonds and gold over the last few years. This was at a time where many fund managers were reducing or removing these assets entirely. The strong performance from gold (+43%) and government bonds (+6%) in the 12 months to March 2020 is one of the key factors that has set Stockspot apart from other robo advisers.

In that period Stockspot’s balanced portfolios averaged a 3-4% return whereas other robo advisers in Australia reported negative returns for their balanced portfolios.

Our defensive approach has also delivered an average 6% p.a. return over 3 years outperforming other robo advisers by ~3% p.a.

Source: Stockspot, other robo adviser websites. The chart shows comparable ‘Balanced’ portfolios (i.e. growth assets between 40-60%) Stockspot also outperformed across all other portfolio risk types. Stockspot is the only robo adviser with a 5 year track record so only 1 and 3 year returns are shown for accurate comparison.

What to look for?

When assessing which robo adviser you want to look after your money, look for one that maintains an allocation to proven defensive assets during good and bad times. These assets will protect you when share markets have corrections.

In a recent AFR article, we shared the following about how Stockspot had been able to protect clients from the brunt of the share market falls.

“They were saved by diversification, with allocations to government bonds and gold helping to offset sharemarket losses”

2. Selecting the best low-cost ETFs

Some of the exchange traded fund (ETF) issuers like Vanguard and Blackrock (iShares) offer their own diversified ETF portfolios.

We are big advocates of the big ETF issuers in Australia, however when they also promote a diversified ETF it is important to recognise that they typically only contain their own products. By being limited to their ETFs you are missing out on superior products elsewhere.

Some other ETF issuers advertise ‘best of breed’ ETF funds but these portfolios only contain their own products, apart from when they don’t have an ETF in a particular asset class. 

Our job as an independent advisor offering a diversified portfolio is to pick the best ETFs in the market. We are continually researching all 200+ of them and publish our research each year for anyone to view.

We use Vanguard funds in some cases but in others we don’t think they are the best option. For example, we currently use the iShares Global 100 ETF (IOO) as our global share ETF whereas Vanguard uses their own Vanguard International Shares Index Fund (VGS).

iShares Global 100 (IOO) has outperformed Vanguard Global Shares (VGS) by a significant margin over 1, 3 and 5 years. We explain why we prefer IOO in this global ETF comparison.

ASX CODEETF NAME1 YEAR RETURN (P.A.)3 YEAR RETURN (% p.a.)5 YEAR RETURN
(% p.a.)
IOOiShares S&P Global 100 ETF10.3%13.1%10.0%
VGSVanguard MSCI Index International Shares ETF 3.9%9.8%7.4%
Data as of 31 March 2020. Source: ASX.

We also use the ETF Securities Gold ETF (GOLD) which neither iShares or Vanguard recommend. Gold has played an important role in cushioning our clients from market volatility over the last year.

Having the flexibility to pick the best ETF for each asset class and being independent from businesses like Vanguard and Blackrock that are manufacturing ETFs gives Stockspot an advantage that can be seen in our returns. The Stockspot Balanced (Turquoise) portfolio has outperformed the equivalent Blackrock and Vanguard funds by a significant margin over all time periods.

Source: Stockspot, Blackrock, Vanguard websites. The chart shows comparable ‘Balanced’ portfolios (i.e. growth assets between 40-60%). Stockspot also outperformed across all other portfolio risk types.

The following table looks at the performance of Stockspot against equivalent Vanguard diversified funds.


1 Year3 Years (p.a.)5 Years (p.a.)
Stockspot Amethyst5.5%6.6%4.7%
Vanguard Conservative0.8%3.4%3.2%
Stockspot outperformance+4.7%+3.2%+1.5%

1 Year3 Years (p.a.)5 Years (p.a.)
Stockspot Turquoise3.0%5.8%4.5%
Vanguard Balanced-1.3%3.5%3.4%
Stockspot outperformance+4.3%+2.3%+1.1%

1 Year3 Years (p.a.)5 Years (p.a.)
Stockspot Topaz0.1%5.3%4.5%
Vanguard Growth-6.7%3.8%3.4%
Stockspot outperformance+6.8%+2.3%+1.2%

1 Year3 Years (p.a.)5 Years (p.a.)
Stockspot average outperformance +5.3%+2.6%+1.3%

What to look for?

Look for a robo adviser that conducts thorough research into the ETF universe, has a regular process for rating and reviewing ETFs, and is independent from the manufacturers of the ETFs.

3. Rebalancing at the right time

Rebalancing is the process of resetting a portfolio back to its target asset weights after asset classes ‘drift’ in value over time. If you need a refresher on why it’s important to rebalance, you can read our recent article. Fund managers have different processes for portfolio rebalancing.

Some fund managers rebalance periodically (i.e. yearly). This is easy for the fund manager to administer but can lead to poor performance for investors who may miss out on better rebalancing opportunities like during the 30% COVID-19 market sell-off.

Other fund managers wait for markets to ‘turn around’ before rebalancing. This is a subjective process and often happens too late. Once market volatility has receded and the economic outlook is clearer, share prices are already higher, so you miss out on buying at low prices.

Stockspot’s rebalancing is threshold based, so when assets move a certain distance from their target weights within a portfolio they are automatically rebalanced. Systematic, threshold based rebalancing has been shown to add 0.91% in portfolio returns.[1] Our rebalancing was in full action mid way through March when we were trimming gold in portfolios and buying shares. This was done across thousands of portfolios in a fully systematised way.

Rebalancing has already added between 0.6% and 1.1% in portfolio returns for the 2020 year so far.

Stockspot Portfolio2020 YTD return WITHOUT rebalancing2020 YTD return WITH rebalancingDifference
Amethyst-0.4%0.2%+0.6%
Sapphire-1.9%-1.3%+0.6%
Turquoise-3.3%-2.3%+1.0%
Emerald-5.1%-4.0%+1.1%
Topaz-6.1%-5.3+0.8%
Returns are calculated after fees as of 30 April 2020

What to look for?

Look for a robo adviser with the process, systems and technology to be able to handle portfolio rebalancing during extreme market volatility. Rebalancing a few weeks late could mean a huge difference in returns.

Robo adviser best practice

In summary, there are 3 areas that have set our performance apart from other robo advisers and ETF issuers over the last 5 years.

1. Choice and weighting of defensive assets
2. Selecting the best low-cost products
3. Rebalancing at the right time

If you use a robo adviser or ETFs more broadly in your portfolio, getting these three factors right could mean a very large difference in returns when the going gets tough.

[1] Vanguard Economic and market outlook 2020

Founder and CEO

Chris has been vocal in calling out the industry 'Fat Cats' and is known for telling it as it is. He sits on two Advisory Committees for the industry regulator ASIC, and was previously a fund manager at UBS. He holds a Bachelor of Commerce (Accounting/Finance Co-op Scholarship) from UNSW.

Grow your wealth effortlessly

Get your free personalised portfolio recommendation

Get started
cloud
Join thousands of Australian already investing with Stockspot